Precision Metal Working: is this undergraduate certificate or diploma worth it?
National picture across 398 reporting college programs.
$47,927 in median year-4 earnings
A credible return for this credential must start with what the student would otherwise earn. The federal data does not provide that personal baseline.
Observed national outcomes
The same field can produce a different equation.
Keep the federal field fixed and compare observed outcomes at every reportable credential level. These are separate graduate cohorts—not a promise that more schooling causes the difference.
Undergraduate Certificate or Diploma
- Year-4 earnings
- $47,927
- Federal debt
- $9,329
- Reporting programs
- 398
Associate's Degree
- Year-4 earnings
- $56,479
- Federal debt
- $12,000
- Reporting programs
- 74
Non-Credential Program (Preparatory Coursework/Teacher Certification)
- Year-4 earnings
- $61,829
- Federal debt
- Not available
- Reporting programs
- 2
Where the middle half of programs lands
Year‑4 earnings differ by college. This band shows the 25th percentile, national median and 75th percentile among reporting programs.
See the spread, not just the national number.
1Riverland Community College$87,8642Idaho State University$82,6833Ferris State University$79,6414White Mountains Community College$71,0745Hennepin Technical College$69,4426Santa Ana College$68,6337Coastal Pines Technical College$68,4438Riverside City College$67,3559Owensboro Community and Technical College$67,17410Alexandria Technical & Community College$65,946Observed year-4 earnings · top displayed records are not a universal ranking
Related occupations
Official CIP–SOC links add career context without claiming that every graduate enters the same job.
Same degree, different outcomes
Compare reported outcomes using the same federal field and credential. Automated ROI is withheld when an exact program price or personal earnings baseline is required.
| # | College | Location | Earnings, year 4 | Federal debt | ROI status | Cost context |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Riverland Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Austin, MN | $87,864 | Not available | Baseline needed | $7,427 |
| 2 | Idaho State UniversityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Pocatello, ID | $82,683 | $9,000 | Baseline needed | $12,193 |
| 3 | Ferris State UniversityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Big Rapids, MI | $79,641 | $21,765 | Baseline needed | $8,624 |
| 4 | White Mountains Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Berlin, NH | $71,074 | $9,625 | Baseline needed | $15,474 |
| 5 | Hennepin Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Brooklyn Park, MN | $69,442 | $9,329 | Baseline needed | $10,272 |
| 6 | Santa Ana CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Santa Ana, CA | $68,633 | Not available | Baseline needed | $3,133 |
| 7 | Coastal Pines Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Waycross, GA | $68,443 | Not available | Baseline needed | Not available |
| 8 | Riverside City CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Riverside, CA | $67,355 | Not available | Baseline needed | $8,377 |
| 9 | Owensboro Community and Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Owensboro, KY | $67,174 | $7,475 | Baseline needed | $5,800 |
| 10 | Alexandria Technical & Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Alexandria, MN | $65,946 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $13,691 |
| 11 | Minnesota North CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Hibbing, MN | $65,172 | Not available | Baseline needed | $10,432 |
| 12 | Butte CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Oroville, CA | $64,811 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,520 |
| 13 | Hawkeye Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Waterloo, IA | $64,717 | $7,874 | Baseline needed | $9,649 |
| 14 | Anoka Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Anoka, MN | $64,648 | $8,692 | Baseline needed | $16,953 |
| 15 | Fox Valley Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Appleton, WI | $63,662 | $7,664 | Baseline needed | $11,407 |
| 16 | Savannah Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Savannah, GA | $63,310 | Not available | Baseline needed | $6,114 |
| 17 | Lee CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Baytown, TX | $62,998 | Not available | Baseline needed | $6,879 |
| 18 | Vincennes UniversityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Vincennes, IN | $62,871 | $9,863 | Baseline needed | $11,225 |
| 19 | Hopkinsville Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Hopkinsville, KY | $62,870 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,875 |
| 20 | Cowley County Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Arkansas City, KS | $62,785 | Not available | Baseline needed | $7,175 |
| 21 | Waukesha County Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Pewaukee, WI | $62,722 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $11,101 |
| 22 | Saint Paul CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Saint Paul, MN | $62,541 | $9,928 | Baseline needed | $11,495 |
| 23 | Alpena Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Alpena, MI | $62,203 | Not available | Baseline needed | $3,320 |
| 24 | Clackamas Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Oregon City, OR | $61,033 | Not available | Baseline needed | $7,855 |
| 25 | Southwest Wisconsin Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Fennimore, WI | $60,707 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $12,896 |
| 26 | Gateway Community and Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Florence, KY | $60,507 | $9,041 | Baseline needed | $5,725 |
| 27 | Bluegrass Community and Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Lexington, KY | $60,198 | $10,684 | Baseline needed | $6,113 |
| 28 | Dunwoody College of TechnologyUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Minneapolis, MN | $60,061 | $6,333 | Baseline needed | $26,939 |
| 29 | Jefferson Community and Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Louisville, KY | $59,962 | $6,794 | Baseline needed | $6,376 |
| 30 | EHOVE Career CenterUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Milan, OH | $59,906 | Not available | Baseline needed | Not available |
| 31 | Northern Michigan UniversityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Marquette, MI | $59,723 | Not available | Baseline needed | $14,085 |
| 32 | Dakota County Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Rosemount, MN | $59,643 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $13,548 |
| 33 | Milwaukee Area Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Milwaukee, WI | $59,516 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $9,112 |
| 34 | Marshalltown Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Marshalltown, IA | $59,331 | Not available | Baseline needed | $8,059 |
| 35 | Tennessee College of Applied Technology-MurfreesboroUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Murfreesboro, TN | $59,112 | Not available | Baseline needed | $6,631 |
| 36 | Hobart Institute of Welding TechnologyUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Troy, OH | $59,016 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $21,409 |
| 37 | Tarrant County College DistrictUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Fort Worth, TX | $59,011 | Not available | Baseline needed | $4,337 |
| 38 | St Cloud Technical and Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Saint Cloud, MN | $58,749 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $9,635 |
| 39 | Connecticut State Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | New Britain, CT | $58,531 | Not available | Baseline needed | $11,513 |
| 40 | West Kentucky Community and Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Paducah, KY | $58,512 | $8,250 | Baseline needed | $5,353 |
| 41 | Central Alabama Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Alexander City, AL | $58,411 | Not available | Baseline needed | $15,996 |
| 42 | Northwest Florida State CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Niceville, FL | $58,333 | Not available | Baseline needed | $4,571 |
| 43 | Lynnes Welding TrainingUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Fargo, ND | $58,273 | $3,700 | Baseline needed | $22,960 |
| 44 | Cisco CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Cisco, TX | $57,960 | Not available | Baseline needed | $9,624 |
| 45 | Moraine Park Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Fond du Lac, WI | $57,861 | $7,000 | Baseline needed | $9,268 |
| 46 | Shelton State Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Tuscaloosa, AL | $57,855 | Not available | Baseline needed | $14,557 |
| 47 | Metropolitan Community College-Kansas CityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Kansas City, MO | $57,729 | Not available | Baseline needed | $8,398 |
| 48 | Baker CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Owosso, MI | $57,680 | Not available | Baseline needed | $13,157 |
| 49 | Del Mar CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Corpus Christi, TX | $57,598 | Not available | Baseline needed | $3,399 |
| 50 | Welder Training and Testing InstituteUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Allentown, PA | $57,411 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $22,503 |
| 51 | Lancaster County Career and Technology CenterUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Willow Street, PA | $56,969 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $17,505 |
| 52 | Advanced Technology InstituteUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Virginia Beach, VA | $56,751 | $12,674 | Baseline needed | $16,358 |
| 53 | Great Oaks Career CampusesUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Cincinnati, OH | $56,665 | $6,078 | Baseline needed | $12,037 |
| 54 | Ogden-Weber Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Ogden, UT | $56,521 | Not available | Baseline needed | $3,229 |
| 55 | Chippewa Valley Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Eau Claire, WI | $56,289 | $8,109 | Baseline needed | $12,285 |
| 56 | East Valley Institute of TechnologyUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Mesa, AZ | $56,189 | Not available | Baseline needed | Not available |
| 57 | Fortis College-Cuyahoga FallsUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Cuyahoga Falls, OH | $56,054 | Not available | Baseline needed | $23,374 |
| 58 | Northern Wyoming Community College DistrictUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Sheridan, WY | $56,041 | Not available | Baseline needed | $9,346 |
| 59 | Bevill State Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Jasper, AL | $55,986 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,937 |
| 60 | Central Lakes College-BrainerdUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Brainerd, MN | $55,654 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $13,869 |
| 61 | Mountainland Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Lehi, UT | $55,570 | Not available | Baseline needed | Not available |
| 62 | North Georgia Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Clarkesville, GA | $55,479 | Not available | Baseline needed | $4,005 |
| 63 | Northeast Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Norfolk, NE | $55,434 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $8,544 |
| 64 | Western Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | La Crosse, WI | $55,158 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $11,008 |
| 65 | Elite Welding Academy LLCUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Cincinnati, OH | $55,098 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $31,701 |
| 66 | Elite Welding Academy South PointUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | South Point, OH | $55,098 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $24,642 |
| 67 | Central Virginia Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Lynchburg, VA | $54,998 | $8,625 | Baseline needed | $6,928 |
| 68 | Danville Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Danville, VA | $54,963 | Not available | Baseline needed | $6,669 |
| 69 | Northwood Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Rice Lake, WI | $54,941 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $8,989 |
| 70 | Montana State UniversityUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Bozeman, MT | $54,930 | Not available | Baseline needed | $22,499 |
| 71 | Gateway Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Kenosha, WI | $54,860 | $9,700 | Baseline needed | $12,928 |
| 72 | Modern Welding SchoolUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Schenectady, NY | $54,806 | $6,790 | Baseline needed | $22,618 |
| 73 | Ridgewater CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Willmar, MN | $54,714 | $9,750 | Baseline needed | $10,046 |
| 74 | South Central CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | North Mankato, MN | $54,263 | $3,666 | Baseline needed | $9,082 |
| 75 | Ranken Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Saint Louis, MO | $54,143 | $9,500 | Baseline needed | $18,795 |
| 76 | Bridgerland Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Logan, UT | $53,913 | Not available | Baseline needed | $2,338 |
| 77 | Indian Hills Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Ottumwa, IA | $53,878 | Not available | Baseline needed | $10,693 |
| 78 | Lake Superior CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Duluth, MN | $53,775 | $13,350 | Baseline needed | $15,492 |
| 79 | Spartanburg Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Spartanburg, SC | $53,755 | Not available | Baseline needed | $2,405 |
| 80 | Ivy Tech Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Indianapolis, IN | $53,579 | $6,387 | Baseline needed | $7,258 |
| 81 | Alaska Vocational Technical CenterUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Seward, AK | $53,551 | Not available | Baseline needed | $12,635 |
| 82 | Lone Star College SystemUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | The Woodlands, TX | $53,293 | $4,562 | Baseline needed | $11,252 |
| 83 | Virginia Western Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Roanoke, VA | $53,278 | Not available | Baseline needed | $4,966 |
| 84 | Kennebec Valley Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Fairfield, ME | $53,244 | Not available | Baseline needed | $3,910 |
| 85 | Laurel Technical InstituteUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Hermitage, PA | $53,141 | Not available | Baseline needed | $6,778 |
| 86 | Mohave Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Kingman, AZ | $53,098 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,974 |
| 87 | Lincoln Land Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Springfield, IL | $53,017 | Not available | Baseline needed | $4,299 |
| 88 | Brightpoint Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Chester, VA | $52,992 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,490 |
| 89 | Georgia Northwestern Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Rome, GA | $52,968 | Not available | Baseline needed | $5,720 |
| 90 | Universal Technical Institute of Arizona IncUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Avondale, AZ | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $30,451 |
| 91 | Universal Technical Institute of Illinois IncUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Lisle, IL | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $27,060 |
| 92 | Universal Technical Institute of California IncUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Rancho Cucamonga, CA | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $26,360 |
| 93 | Universal Technical Institute-MooresvilleUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Mooresville, NC | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $28,915 |
| 94 | Universal Technical Institute-Southern CaliforniaUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Long Beach, CA | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $27,506 |
| 95 | Universal Technical Institute-South Florida MiramarUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Miramar, FL | $52,936 | $10,593 | Baseline needed | $28,759 |
| 96 | Tennessee College of Applied Technology-MemphisUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Memphis, TN | $52,924 | Not available | Baseline needed | $14,315 |
| 97 | Front Range Community CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Westminster, CO | $52,873 | $8,347 | Baseline needed | $13,031 |
| 98 | Northcentral Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Wausau, WI | $52,792 | $5,250 | Baseline needed | $10,303 |
| 99 | Northeast Wisconsin Technical CollegeUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Green Bay, WI | $52,759 | $5,500 | Baseline needed | $9,918 |
| 100 | Tennessee College of Applied Technology-PulaskiUndergraduate Certificate or Diploma | Pulaski, TN | $52,577 | Not available | Baseline needed | $15,269 |
This page keeps the field and credential level fixed. Federal categories can still combine multiple catalog programs or concentrations. Automated ROI is limited to associate and bachelor’s degrees because institution-wide annual net price is not a reliable proxy for short certificate prices. ROI is an illustrative scenario, not a federal determination.